09 Jul 2010
REVIEW: Avatar – The Last Airbender (2010)
Film: (Avatar) The Last Airbender
Director: M. Night Shamalyan
Plot: Air, Water, Earth, Fire. Four nations tied by destiny when the Fire Nation launches a brutal war against the others. A century has passed with no hope in sight to change the path of this destruction. Caught between combat and courage, Aang (Noah Ringer) discovers he is the lone Avatar with the power to manipulate all four elements. Aang teams with Katara (Nicola Peltz), a Waterbender, and her brother, Sokka (Jackson Rathbone), to restore balance to their war-torn world.
Based on the hugely successful Nickelodeon animated TV series, the live-action feature film “The Last Airbender” is the opening chapter in Aang’s struggle to survive.
That’s right i called it Avatar, James Cameron can suck it, Avatar was overrated anyway. If you’ve ever seen the cartoon then you’ll immediatley know the character and plot of the three seasons or books, the movie version attempts to cover the first season from start to finish. I originally intended to do a full review with some minor spoilers but over the last week since i started writing this i realized that the majority of the people who would read this either watched the show or read another review about the movie. So i’m gonna break it down into good and bad sections, first up, the Good.
Good: The film is very epic in size and rivals things like The Chronicles of Narnia in sheer scale and production, despite what anyone might say about the content of the film itself the production value is spectacular. The special effects are very good, i understand its hard to make CG wind but it actually looked convincing (some of the reactions from stunt players seemed a little cheesy though), the firebending, earthbending, and waterbending all looked top notch.
Some of the acting was actually surprisingly good, Dev Patel stepped up here and made quite the convincing Zuko, he was actually the only cast member i was worried about in the beginning i loved him in Slumdog Millionare but i wasnt sure if he could manage to be as angry and emotional as season 1 Zuko was, I was pleasantly surprised. Shaun Toub as Uncle Iroh was another bright spot in the cast, his performance as the wise yet emotionally troubled uncle of Zuko was one of the best in the film, if only the rest of the cast could have followed his lead, but more on that later.
The costume design was also superb, they pretty much stuck exactly to the show, everything from Aang’s outfit to the Fire Nation uniforms and the Northern water tribe’s outfits.
Bad: Had enough of the good? Well then you’re in time for the bad, or really the less than good because it wasnt as bad as most critics have claimed, here goes. First off, the elephant in the room, the bad racial casting i dont mean casting an English guy to play an American and swapping accents i mean taking characters that are supposed to be from Inuit tribes and making them extremely caucasian, not even a little tan. This wouldnt be such an issue if they would have made all the Water tribe caucasion, instead for some reason they cast people who actually looked Inuit to play in the background shots, when the main stars stand in a group they look like adopted kids. Pretty much any water bender with a speaking role is caucasian with some kind of braided hair. A lot of people it found it controversial that the Fire Nation had been recast completely, in the show they were easily Japanese influenced while the Earth Nation appeared to be more Chinese influenced, well the producers thought it would make sense to recast the entire Fire Nation as Indian (like from India). Oddly the Earth Nation actually remained Asian (i think everyone was shocked). For the exception of Zuko and Uncle Iroh most of the cast seemed out of place, Aang specifically. Young Noah Ringer seemed very torn on how to play the character, he easily looked the part but he always seemed to be struggling with his delivery of lines, like he was over thinking them. This would have been fine, if he werent the lead character. His lacking performance brings me to my second biggest problem with the movie, its heart is gone.
In the show all of the main characters are very light hearted, and even though they all have serious moments theres a lot of comedy between them. In the big screen adaption pretty much all of the comedy is gone. This is a terrible crime because the characters like Sokka, Momo, and Appa are the main comedy relief in the show. Aside from two to three moments in the film there’s no real comedy, Sokka is serious most of the time, Momo only gets about 3 minutes of screen time, and Appa gets about the same with one joke toward the beginning. Its a shame because this is what made the show unique and beloved, it was a great adventure story but the characters were heavy on fun and heart.
My other big problem with the film, the pacing. Looking at other big budget epics like Lord of the Rings, Harry Potter or Chronicles of Narnia, these films are between two and three hours allowing them to flesh out the details, establish characters, create enemies, and allow the viewers to better understand the source material. In The Last Airbender the entire movie is cut to be just about 100 minutes or about an hour and forty five minutes. Trying to fit the contents of a twenty episode season into that time is near impossible and the end result comes out painfully rushed. Entire story arcs like Sokka and Princess Yue’s courtship are crushed from 3 episodes down to about 5 minutes so if you’ve never seen the show you wont develop a relationship to Princess Yue’s character who becomes a big part of the film and a major story point for Sokka. The pacing of the entire film just felt overly rushed as if they didnt think kids and adults seeing this film in theaters would have the attention span to sit through a two and a half hour film, its because of this that the film suffers as they rush through places not even giving a mention to minor characters, instead providing barely a montage of events before they reach the Northern Water tribe.
Bottom Line: If you were a fan of the show and can look past the obvious Racebending (my new favorite online term to describe the whitewashing of characters in the film) you’ll find a film thats almost halfway decent, sadly the more you start to think about it as a fan the more its gonna piss you off.
If you werent a fan of the series or hadnt even heard of it then you’re gonna have a pretty hard time understanding it, partly because of the nature of the source material, but mostly because of the films badly rushed pacing.
-My final verdict on Avatar: The Last Airbender













